Monday, August 31, 2009

List of Approved Writers

The following is a list, by student, of the approved writers for your research paper topics:
  • Brotemarkle, Deanna - Louisa May Alcott
  • Glenn, Sylvia - Anne Bradstreet
  • Mikles, Jessica - Emily Dickinson
  • Murtha, Justin - Edgar Allen Poe
  • O'Donnell, Tracy - Thomas Paine
  • Ratcliffe, Denise - William Bradford
  • Reid , Shawneequa - Edgar Allen Poe
  • Smith, Lauryn - Black Hawk
  • Strange, Stephanie - Nathaniel Hawthorne
  • Thompson, Charlotta - Harriet Beecher Stowe
  • Tooley, Christopher - Henry David Thoreau
  • Vang, Kong - Nathaniel Hawthorne

If I have "no list" beside your name, I have not received a list of your three possible writers. You need post your list with your reasons for being interested in the writer as a blog entry. Edgar Allen Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne are no longer an options because two students already have it as the source of their research paper topics.

If you want to negotiate with people and trade writers, please feel free. Just let me know what you worked out.

Saturday, August 29, 2009

The Captivity of Weetamoo

In her August 27 blog entry, Denise Ratcliffe points out that the Indians in Mary Rowlandson's narrative didn't have it much better than she did. A case in point is Weetamoo, the wife of Rowlandson's Indian "master," Quanopin.

Since Quanopin is frequently absent, Rowlandson is essentially at the mercy of this woman. Though Rowlandson doesn't see it as such, one of Weetamoo's first actions is an act of kindness. Rowlandson sees her son because Weetamoo "brought him to see me." (216).

On the "fifth Remove" Weetamoo is less kind: "Being very faint I asked my mistress to give me one spoonfull of the meal, but she would not give me a taste." (219) Weetamoo is generally stingy with food, and Rowlandson often gets food from other squaws.

There is a telling moment during the "twelfth remove." The Indians are backtracking toward where Rowlandson had been captured and she is in better spirits. But Weetamoo is not: ". . . on a sudden my mistress gives out, she would go no further, but [would] turn back again, and said, I must go back again with her; and she called her Sannup [husband], and would have had him gone back also, but he would not . . . [224]

Later Weetamoo asks Rowlandson to give her a piece of her apron to make a flap for her baby. When Rowlandsan refuses, Weetamoo "takes up a stick big enough to have killed me, and struck at me with it . . ." The incident is settled when Rowlandson gives Weetamoo's maid "all my Apron." (226-27)

But Weetamoo's sadness moment occurs during the "thirteenth remove." Rowlandson is noticably unmoved when she writes: "my Mistress's Papoos was sick, and it died that night, and there was one benefit in it, that there was more room." (228) We are meant to be shocked by how casual the Indians are about the death of Rowlandson's daughter. Yet Rowlandson can't muster any sympathy for an Indian mother who has also lost her child.

During the "nineteenth remove" we get crucial background information: Weetamoo is the second of her husband's three wives. During many of his absences, he has been staying with his first wife and his third wife is "a younger one, by whom had had two Papooses." (232) At this point Rowlandson sums up Weetamoo as a "severe and proud Dame . . . bestowing every day in dressing herself neat as much time as any of the Gentry of the land. . ." (231)

But can there be another perspective on Weetamoo's life? She is the middle of three wives, the older was her husband's first love, the third has given him children. Was the child she lost, the only child she had? When she asked Rowlandson for a piece of apron for her baby, was she trying to keep an ailing child alive under rigorous conditions?

Quanopin and Weetamoo dress up to participate in the "great day of Dancing." But later during the celebration Quanopin gets drunk. He calls Mr. Hoar a "good man" yet wants to hang him as a rogue. Rowlandson is frighten when she sees Quanopin in this state.

Here is the last image we have of him and Weetamoo: "his Squaw ran out, and he after her, round the Wigwam, with his money jingling at his knees; But she escaped him: But having an old Squaw he ran to her; and so through the Lord's mercy, we were no more troubled that night." (236)

At the end of her narrative, Mary Rowlandson is restored to a happy life. But if you piece together Weetamoo's story, you can only wonder what kind of troubled life lies ahead for her.

On the "Three Writers" Assignment

I've looked through your blogs. A number of you didn't provide as much detail as I wanted about the three writers you were considering for your paper.

For examples of what I wanted done, see the blogs for the following students:
  • Jessica Mikles
  • Denise Ratcliffe
  • Lauryn Smith
  • Christopher Tooley
Read what they have done and make changes to your own blog.

If you have any questions, you can ask them in class or enter them as comments to this blog entry.

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Whitman as Storyteller

The next-to-last section of "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" consists entirely of a series of questions. Here's the last half of the section:

What is more subtle than this which ties me to the woman or man that looks in my face?
Which fuses me into you now, and pours my meaning into you?

We understand then do we not?
What I promis'd without mentioning it, have you not accepted?
What the study could not teach --- what the preaching could not accomplish is accomplished, is it not?

The first questions are "rhetorical." Whitman expects you to agree that nothing is more subtle than the unnamed "this" that "connects" people when they look at each other, that "fuses" Whitman the poet with the person reading his poem and allows him to "pour" his "meaning" into the reader.

The remaining questions have an urgency. "Did I succeed in conveying my meaning?" Whitman asks. "Did my human experience come across and did you accept it as one human being to another?"

To apply Whitman's own metaphor to poetry: a poem is a "ferry" that allows a poet's meaning to cross over to another person, just as a real ferry conveys people from one place to another place. It is important to insist that the poem carries a person. What a poem conveys is life experience, not "information."

To illuminate that distinction let me refer to Walter Benjamin's essay, "The Storyteller." In that essay Benjamin declares that storytelling involves our "ability to exchange experiences." The modern age, he believes, is taking that ability away from us. Instead we are pumped full of information that "lays claim to prompt verifiability. The prime requirement is that it appear 'understandable in itself.'"

Here's his conclusion about the difference between storytelling and information.

Every morning brings us the news of the globe . . . no event any longer comes to us without already being shot through with explanation. . . .it is half the art of story telling to keep a story free from explanation as one reproduces it. . . . The most extraordinary things, marvelous things, are related with the greatest accuracy, but the psychological connection of the events is not forced on the reader. It is left up to him to interpret things the way he understands them, and thus the narrative achieves an amplitude that information lacks.

I would make the same claim for Whitman. In his poem he wants to convey his experience of himself and the world --- he doesn't want to just provide his reader with information that strips life of its wonder and "explains" it away.

Tuesday, August 18, 2009

Learning to be Human

The thing about a blog is that you can use it like a notebook to jot down stray thoughts before they totally abandon you. And very often, if you read a lot, you stumble across thoughts that attract you.

Such is the case with the following passages from Hannah Arendt's "Thoughts About Lessing," an "address" she gave "on accepting the Lessing Prize of the Free City of Hamburg" (as the footnote says).

"For the world is not humane just because it is made by human beings, and it does not become humane just because the human voice sounds in it, but only when it has become the object of discourse. However much we are affected by the things of the world, however deeply they may stir and stimulate us, they become human for us only when we can discuss them with our fellows. . . . We humanize what is going on in the world and in ourselves only by speaking of it, and in the course of speaking of it we learn to be human."

It's a long passage, but I'm not finished yet. Being an "intellectual" of her time Hannah Arendt couldn't resist throwing in some scholarly information. She continues.

"The Greeks called this humaness which is achieved in the discourse of friendship philianthropia, 'love of man,' since it manifests itself in a readiness to share the world with other men. It's opposite, misanthropy, means simply that the misanthrope finds no one with whom he cares to share the world, that he regards nobody as worthy of rejoicing with him in the world and nature and the cosmos."

For my taste these are full-blooded thoughts --- dark ale, not Bud Lite. For others, it might just be a lot of rhetoric that buries a simple idea. I can already hear the complaint: the sentences are too long!

Even though the quote is somewhat outside the realm of American Lit, I have my reasons for bringing it up. But, since this is an informal blog, I don't have to give you my reasons.

Just consider this another example of what you can do in blog.

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Hurry and Crudeness

I love quotes, so I'll start this blog with one from Walt Whitman's preface to Specimen Days:

". . . we give long preparations for some object, planning and delving and fashioning, and then, when the actual hour for doing arrives, find ourselves still quite unprepared, and tumble the thing together, letting hurry and crudeness tell the story better than fine work."

All I'm doing in this entry is taking the first step, touching pen to paper to dispel the blank page's power to intimidate. (Only these days you are more likely to be touching the key that types the word on the blank screen.)

In this class I will be asking all of you to keep your own blogs as a way of getting you to "think" on paper (or at your PC screen). I expect errors in your blog entries -- there will be errors (typographical or otherwise) in my own blog, but that's the point. I want to free you to write down your thoughts in "hurry and crudeness" with the idea that you can return and make those initial entries into "fine work."

So I dare you to begin, to take the first step and write your first entry.

I look forward to seeing what springs from your restless, sometimes sleepy, but always energetic minds.