Thursday, November 12, 2009

Sunday, November 8, 2009

Saturday, October 31, 2009

Emerson's Argument for Idealism

Having presented the "uses" of nature for the soul under four classes, Emerson might have concluded his essay "Nature," yet he continues for three more sections. The first of these sections is a defense of "idealism," the belief that nature might not outwardly exist.

Emerson knows that common sense rebels against even the possibility that the world around us does not exist. How can buildings, mountains, oceans --- of which individual human beings are such a small part --- not exist! We are part of nature; nature is not part of us. The very suggestion is absurd.

To be fair to Emerson (and a substantial body of philosophy), let me summarize his argument.

It Does Not Make a Difference to the Individual
For the individual human being whether the world physically exists as separate from his sense impressions doesn't matter. Here's what Emerson says:
In my utter impotence to test the authenticity of the report of my senses, to know whether the impressions they make on me correspond with outlying objects, what difference does it make, whether Orion is up there in heaven, or some god paints the image in the firmament of the soul? . . . Whether nature enjoys a substantial existence without, or is only in the apocalypse of my mind, it is alike useful and alike venerable to me. Be it what it may, it is ideal to me so long as I cannot try the accuracy of my senses. (967)
Culture Emphasizes Spirit, Nature is Secondary
The rest of Emerson's argument deals with the effect culture has on the individual's perception of the world. Here's another important quote.
It is the universal effect of culture on the human mind . . . to lead us to regard nature as a phenomena, not a substance; to attribute necessary existence to spirit; to esteem nature as an accident and an effect. (967)
1. Nature's Hints to the Sensual Man
Even for the ordinary man, Nature hints at a "dualism," a key difference between "the observer and the spectacle, between man and nature." The world can be made to "look" very different just by getting on a moving coach, ship, or balloon. The simple of act of "looking at the landscape through your legs" gives you a different perspective on the world. (968)

2. The Poet's Use of Nature
The poet looks at the world . . . and makes poetry: "He unfixes the land and the sea, makes them revolve around the axis of his primary thought, and disposes them anew." The poet uses his "imagination" to "subordinate nature for the purposes of expression." (968) Here's Emerson's conclusion:
The perception of real affinities between events (that is to say, of ideal affinities, for those only are real), enables the poet thus to make free with the most imposing forms and phenomena of the world, and to assert the predominance of the soul. (970)
3. The Philosopher's Use of Nature
The philosopher also "animates nature with his own thoughts." The only difference between the philosopher's and the poet's use of nature is that the poet "proposes Beauty as his main end" and the philosopher proposes "Truth." (970) In both cases, nature is subservient to the uses of the mind.

4. Science Doubts the Existence of Matter
The practice of scientific inquiry, Emerson believes, also produces "invariably a doubt of the existence of matter" because it "fastens the attention upon immortal necessary uncreated natures, that is, upon Ideas; and in their presence we feel the outward circumstance is a dream and a shade." (970)

5. Religion and Ethics Make Nature Dependent on Spirit
The final element in his argument based on culture is Emerson's conclusion that religion and ethics "have analoguous effect with all lower culture, in degrading nature and suggesting its dependency on spirit." The only difference between religion and ethics is that:
". . . the one system is the system of human duties commencing from man; the other, from God. Religion includes the personality of God; Ethics does not." (971)
Last Thoughts
Emerson concludes by saying he is not an advocate of idealism per se, but only to the point that it helps him "indicate the true position of nature in regard to man" and because idealism "presents the world in precisely that view which is most desirable to the mind." (972)

In other words, idealism makes us the center of the world. It makes our actions in the world important, not for the world itself (which may be primarily an illusion), but for a person's soul, the most important and real thing in an individual's life.

The Quality of the Day

There are two Thoreaus: Thoreau the naturalist and Thoreau the moralist. Most of the time he speaks directly as either one or the other. At other times the two are mingled, and I sometimes wish I could apply a filter to those passages to remove the moralist and listen more clearly to the naturalist.

Frankly, Thoreau the moralist, in too great a dose, can be irritating . His points are usually valid, but he expresses them with too much self-importance and too little sympathy for the mass of men who, as he says, "consenting to be deceived by shows . . . establish and confirm their daily life of routine and habit." (1684) When he really gets going, he can sound like this:
It is something to be able to paint a particular picture, or to carve a statue, and so to make a few objects beautiful; but it is far more glorious to carve and paint the very atmosphere and medium through which we look, which morally we can do. To affect the quality of the day, that is the highest art. Every man is tasked to make his life, even in its details, worthy of the contemplation of his most elevated and critical hour. (1681)
Why does Thoreau load down the simple pleasures of carving and painting with the weight of a moral task? Why not simply carve and paint? Why should contemplation always produce a moral lesson?
It is Thoreau the naturalist who simply carves and paints. The results, taken by themselves, are often more satisfying than the moral lectures that surround them. Which is another way of saying that Thoreau writes some pretty good descriptions. Unfortunately, most people do not have the patience or the skill to read a descriptive passage simply as description.

When Thoreau admonishes us to "spend one day as deliberately as Nature," (1685) he knows most of us are too impatient to succeed even for half a day. But even if the time spent outside ourselves is only a fleeting moment, it still can produce wonderful effects. I'll conclude this entry with one of Thoreau's descriptions and the advice to enjoy it simply as a word-painting.
For the first week, whenever I looked out on the pond it impressed me like a tarn up on the side of a mountain, its bottom far above the surface of other lakes, and, as the sun arose, I saw it throwing off its nightly clothing of mist, and here and there, by degrees, its soft ripples or its smooth reflecting surface was revealed, while the mists, like ghosts, were steathily withdrawing in every direction into the woods, as at the breaking up of some nocturnal conventicle. The very dew seemed to hang upon the trees later in the day than usual, as on the sides of the mountains. (1678)

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Wednesday, October 21, 2009