Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Franklin's Habit of Modesty

Early in his Autobiography, Benjamin Franklin declares that "Prose Writing has been of great Use to me in the Course of my Life, and was a principal Means of My Advancement." (349) Given its importance, he spends a number of pages recounting how he acquired and developed his writing skills.

For Franklin, a key writing skill was being able to develop an argument, a method of convincing people to accept your ideas. Although his father had "Books of Dispute about Religion," Franklin felt that type of argument wasn't effective. He didn't find a method that impressed him until he acquired a grammar book that concluded with a "Specimen of a Dispute in the Socratic Method." Franklin was so "charm'd" with the method that he "adopted it, dropt my abrupt Contradiction, and positive Argumentation, and put on the humble Enquirer and Doubter." (351)

According to Franklin, the Socratic method consisted of "drawing People . . . into concessions the Consequences of which they did not foresee, entangling them in Difficulties out of which they could not extricate themselves, and so obtaining Victories that neither my self nor my Cause always deserved." As my quote shows, Franklin recognized, from the beginning, the limitations of the Socratic approach and, as he says, "gradually left it, retaining only the Habit of expressing my self in Terms of modest Diffidence." (352)

Franklin presents himself as a believer in dialogue instead of debate. For him, the "chief Ends of Conversation are to inform, or to be informed, to please or to persuade." (352) In a debate, the people talking do not want to inform or being informed; all they want to do is to win. No one can be persuaded or informed if the approach is blatantly adversarial.

It's easy to imagine Franklin shaking his head at the shouting matches that pass for public discourse these days, but I suspect that people in his day were just as prone to shouting --- they just didn't have the technology to instantly project grunting and snarling around the world. In terms of intelligent conversation, technology may actually be taking us a step backwards.

No comments:

Post a Comment