Tuesday, September 8, 2009

"Painful Considerations" - Woolman and Edwards

Stylistically, John Woolman and Jonathan Edwards are a study in contrasts. Woolman's prose is straight forward and understated, while Edwards' is convoluted and bombastic. Temperamentally they are different too, yet each of them believes in a direct and powerful connection with God. And its hard to believe that connection should not also be powerfully emotional.

In our anthology the introduction to Woolman summarizes Quaker beliefs by pointing out their "religious ecstasies and their insistence that men should 'tremble at the word of God.'" It goes on to say they "taught the doctrine of 'inner light,' that direct communication with God is possible," but they also rejected the "Puritan doctrines of total depravity and of limited atonement." (245-55)

Regarding Edwards, the anthology states, "His faith was both mystical and logical. He preached the power of God and the depravity of man, and he argued that God's grace might be recognized by the mystical, inward 'supernatural sense' that God gave to the regenerate believer." Edwards himself calls it his "inward, sweet delight in God and divine things."

But although Edwards talks often about his "delight in God and divine things," we don't get the sense of a happy man. In fact, Edwards is more often assailed by a "vastly greater sense of my own wickedness." He calls it "an abyss infinitely deeper than hell" and seems relentlessly drawn to this dark side. (275) Edwards might "delight" in God and divine things, but he does not include himself among those "divine things," so he naturally tends toward self hatred

Woolman is a more restrained and seemingly balanced man. His statements, even when they are dark, flow mildly with a constrained logic. He doesn't seem tossed around by his passions. He's more likely to be "convinced" than "converted." The understatement in this explanation is characteristic of him: "I kept steady to meetings . . . and was early convinced in my mind that true religion consisted in an inward life, wherein the heart doth love and reverence God the Creator and learn to exercise true justice and goodness, not only toward all men but toward the brute creatures." (257)

The brief excepts from Woolman's journal don't offer a lot of proof, but I believe that Woolman's temperament, like his prose style, reflects a powerful will that controls passions every bit as dark and powerful as Edwards'.

The strongest evidence I have is his depiction of his actions regarding the mother robin and her chicks. He kills the mother accidentally, as a child would; but he kills the chicks based on a relentless logic. Here's how he expresses it: "after some painful considerations on the subject, I climbed up the tree, took all the young birds and killed them, supposing that better than to leave them to pine away and die miserably . . ." (256) I wonder what turmoil lies under that simple phrase, "painful considerations"? Edwards might have spent paragraphs sharing that pain with us, but Woolman probably feels, quite logically, that no point is served.

Given how controlled he seems, it's strange that Woolman would even write any of this down. But he offers an explanation in the first sentence of journal: "I have often felt a motion of love to leave some hints in writing of my experience of the goodness of God." (255)

Jonathan Edwards offers us a storm of emotion, of sweet delights and dark self-hatred. Perhaps Woolman also feels that storm of emotion, but he is careful to explain that he is only giving us "hints" of his experience. He, unlike Edwards, does not lay bare the agonies of his soul. He only offers us enough of his experience as might be useful.

2 comments:

  1. This was an awesome explanation of Woolman, and everything I was thinking about him but couldnt put down. He was solidly steadfast and focused to the point of my envying that characteristic of him.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks.

    You realize, of course, that I was speculating -- and that to really bolster my point I would need to read not only all of Woolman's journal, but a reputable biography of him.

    ReplyDelete